Seller gave full disclosure:
"Record Condition: Poor (1/2 inch crack on edge of both sides, plays through but could skip on your system) filler copy please no returns, as is"...
Here's one notable
http://m.ebay.com/itm/THE-NOBLEMEN-Short-Time-on-Orlyn-Ultra-Rare-60s-Chicago-Garage-Rock-/222582858737?hash=item33d2f8e3f1%3Ag%3AxlMAAOSwuq9Zamow&_trkparms=pageci%253Afbdc62d4-7156-11e7-9a4a-74dbd18096c3%257Cparentrq%253A7a98959715d0ab640b5d279afffcc229%257Ciid%253A1
I think that the two of you should agree to disagree on this issue, but I must make a point to MTM who says:
"Therefore, the consent will be that this 45 sold for X dollars in VG condition - when it was really G minus at best. This often affects asking prices for any true VG condition and...
That makes some sense. It's still a lot to pay for a cracked record. I do give credit to the seller for (presumably) full disclosure. Some might have deliberately failed to mention the crack then claimed it happened in the mail. We all know a dealer or two who may have done that.