I don't listen to either, the only Charlatans record in my collection is the Kapp 45 with P/S, doing half baked (or more likely - completely "baked") remakes of the Coasters and Robert Johnson. Back when I first started collecting 60s stuff, the Charlatans were name checked as some kind of legendary band, peers of the Airplane and Elevators, Band Zero of the San Francisco Sound, blah blah blah.....yawn. I guess I can't put all the crap out of my mind and listen to them as just another band that recorded a 45 and LP or so of demos.