I mostly agree, visually. However colored vinyl has one important advantage over black vinyl. The pigment used in black vinyl contains magnetic residue that needs to be treated with a demagnetizer to prevent voice coil interference as the record spins. Assuming the pressing is not faulty and is clean, colored vinyl plays perfectly from the factory. It contains no magnetic residue so it does not need to be demagnetized. The difference is clearly audible and surprising - black vinyl pressings have constricted high frequencies, reduced dynamic range and messed-up imaging until they are demagnetized. Some companies sell "special pressings" for hundreds of bucks which are just regular black vinyl pressings that have been demagnetized!
Here is more information about the Furutech DeMag device I use to demagnetize my black vinyl records. (Mine is actually the newer model called the DeMag Alpha)
