wyldasslpman
Tower Class
- Joined
- Apr 26, 2011
- Location
- pa.
i'm in for one as well
At this point in time, the apex of discographical reference works of any genre must be Mario Panciera's "45 Revolution" book on uk 45s punk/post-punk/etc 45s released between 1976 and '79. With 1200 pages, 4500 color cover reproductions, 100s of band interviews conducted, exact release dates, line-ups, quotes from period music papers, printed on high quality paper and housed in a hardcover, it's everything genre-fiends could ever hope to get. Admittedly it's harder to cover a genre thats two decades older and broader, but if TBM will be close to "45 revolution" standards, it will be a monument. Coincidentally, Panciera's book cost 85 euro which about equals $100.
The other reason why a publishedTBM would have been a wasted effort in the '80s, (or even in 1996, when I was going to have it published by now defunct Popular Culture Ink - thank God that fell thru!) - the amount of time it took to research recordings, track groups, and all else required a self-sacrifice and high standard. I'm not saying that other people didn't possess such qualities, but most of the collectors I know did not want to even think about trying to start a project like this. Greg Shaw soon realized he'd never get a handle on the scope of the task at hand, something we discussed via e-mails when I was getting started. He quickly realized that doing a book which just recycled directly from other sources was not gonna be a worthy effort. Then you had people like Tom Tourville. I've never met the man, but his books, cranked out cheaply on a photocopy machine, were examples of how NOT to do a book on the subject. Right idea, but he didn't know how to do research and validate his information. Printing unsubstantiated "heresay" was, and still is the lazy man method of publishing information that will be referenced by the readership.
For a book such as this, I would go so far as to say hardcover is not so much necessary as it is mandatory. Like a lot of folks here, I have no problem shelling out the extra cash for hardcover; in my own experience softcovers tend to fall apart too damn easily (see: Joynson, Vernon).
Mike, how did you precisely proceed to avoid any hearsays or 2nd/3rd order informations in your book ? Did you get in touch with at least a member of all bands featured, especially when it came to write down the band histories ? I suppose that it's not been the case, as such task is probably impossible... or did you indeed ? would be curious to know...