The Beatles In Mono - vinyl box set

[quote="axel, post: 32182"

Truely speaking: they should have taken more time, write a couple more songs, let Brian Wilson do his thing, whenever he gets it ready. He would have needed a lot more time anyway. And everybody would be happy! (well, except for you garage guys who don't like pop sike anyway, hahaha!)[/quote]

Axel Dude, you RULE with this topic.

But it may be seen, in some open minded conclaves, as so, well, Yesterday.

Piper being the real time Pepper, after all...:sunny:
 
I can't stand "She's Leaving Home". I actually prefer "When You Wish Upon A Star". It's more uplifting and has more energy.
I wouldn't expect you to like it. But I'm sure Brian Wilson died when he heard it. Imagine an arrangement like Caroline No. The song itself is immaculate. Mel Torme's version is one of the few versions of a Beatles song that might be better than the original. Definitely more uplifting! Sadly it's not on youtube.
 
But it may be seen, in some open minded conclaves, as so, well, Yesterday.
Piper being the real time Pepper, after all...:sunny:
Thanks, Sounddog. I agree, Piper is the real thing.

Sorry to ask, but what do you mean with "Yesterday"?
 
Anyway Axel, if anyone could convince me to give Sgt. Pepper another listen, you're the one! Some of it I do like already, it's only about half that bugs me.

I think you could make a great double LP of the Beatles psychedelic / progressive pop titles. I will do it in a little while. I might even make it a triple.
 
By the way, I'm just listening to the Crystal Syphon LP, which I was very late in getting. At this very moment I'd put my head quite far above the parapet and say even that is better than Sgt.Pepper's. There you go!
 
OH MY GOD!!! I forgot "Getting Better" in the Revolver/Pepper's juxtaposition. McCartney is ALWAYS winning by a nose! :boggle::sonny::sunny::oops:
 
Anyway Axel, if anyone could convince me to give Sgt. Pepper another listen,
But please on British Parlophone first press stereo. That is the only way to go. It makes a LOT of difference. I know that you dig a good mix. And Geoff Emerick is working magic there. It's quite an experience (no matter how bad the songs. Hahaha!).
 
please on British Parlophone first press stereo.
Just listening to Getting Better and Fixing A Hole. The drums! The guitar licks! The vocals! And, that thumping heavy bass!!! PERFECTION! Give it a try.
 
I couldn't do a triple LP, it had to be a 4LP box set. The idea is to combine all the best tracks from ANY year, that sound like mid/late '60s psych/progressive pop. I left out all the twee, novelty cuts like Rocky Raccoon etc. I also left out the boring dirges like "Hey Jude". I included a track like "I Feel Fine" because it has a psychedelic undercurrent in the instrumentation, and a sophisticated song structure.

1a
Tomorrow Never Knows
Revolution (45 version)
Because
Dear Prudence
If I Needed Someone
Rain
Helter Skelter
A Day In The Life

1b
Back In The U.S.S.R.
Good Day Sunshine
I’m Only Sleeping
Get Back
Getting Better
I Feel Fine
Yellow Submarine
I Am The Walrus

2a
Taxman
Norwegian Wood
Mother Nature’s Son
Across The Universe
In My Life
Nowhere Man
Strawberry Fields Forever
All You Need Is Love

2b
Good Morning Good Morning
Birthday
Come Together
I’ve Got A Feeling
Paperback Writer
I’m So Tired
The Inner Light
She Said She Said

3a
Being For The Benefit Of Mr. Kite
Lucy In The Sky With Diamonds
Lovely Rita
Sexy Sadie
Yellow Submarine
Magical Mystery Tour
Within You Without You

3b
Sergeant Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band
Penny Lane
Hello Goodbye
Doctor Robert
Fixing A Hole
Glass Onion
And Your Bird Can Sing
Sergeant Pepper’s Lonely Hearts Club Band (Reprise)

4a
I Want To Tell You
Here, There And Everywhere
For No-One
I Need You
I Will
Julia
Wait
Every Little Thing

4b
Everybody’s Got Something To Hide…Monkey
Here Comes The Sun
You Never Give Me Your Money
Sun King
Mean Mr. Mustard
Polythene Pam
She Came In Through The Bathroom Window
The End
 
I had the honor to meet Richard Hamilton in person about 20 years ago. He was friends with my screenprint professor at university and followed his invite to talk and discuss art with around 12 students attending the screenprint course.
He was very vivid, wise and everything he said was inspiring and interesting. Very adorable. A great person. Being the only "retro" guy in class I asked him about the White Album and he was happy someone knew it was his work. He said the Beatles wanted something "that hadn’t been done before" and that was "very different from Sgt. Pepper's", artwork-wise. And then he came up with the idea of making it: just white. The Beatles loved it immediately, he said, although they had expected something else.

I like the White Album. Though it is scattered and feels a bit "undone", there are so many great songs, melodies and ideas on it. I will never get how someone can even hate The Beatles. They are the center of the universe.
 
Only A Northern Song could have been a masterpiece with lyrics that meant something. I got the impression the only meaning was no meaning, which is at least amusing. Then again, I rate Kilroy Was Here by The Move a certifiable classic and like the Emotions album by The Pretty Things a bit more than S.F. Sorrow.

The first Beatles song that went beyond anything before it to me was There's A Place. I think that was a John song? I wondered if he'd heard/read Bob Dylan then?

For some reason Rita Meter-maid was on the radio here a lot/waytoo much in the '70s-80s, and a few others... it really did make us sick of The Beatles. Whenever those Past Masters comps first came out was when I got turned back on to them.
 
I couldn't do a triple LP, it had to be a 4LP box set. The idea is to combine all the best tracks from ANY year, that sound like mid/late '60s psych/progressive pop. I left out all the twee, novelty cuts like Rocky Raccoon etc. I also left out the boring dirges like "Hey Jude". I included a track like "I Feel Fine" because it has a psychedelic undercurrent in the instrumentation, and a sophisticated song structure.

1a
Tomorrow Never Knows...
That is awesome, Mark! I'd buy it right away, although I have most of it multiply.
 
I did consider including both of those. But they just seemed to waffle on a bit.
You mean the lyrics? Well, but for a psychedelic/progressive Beatles album they are essential. Musically they are the most psychedelic of all their songs. Really adventurous stuff. Highly psychedelic sounds and mixing.
"Only A Northern Song"'s lyrics are pretty good, too. A very amusing comment on writing songs on acid using strange chords. With a song that is exactly doing that. And then saying: you may think they're wrong, but they're not, they're meant to be that way. I love that kind of humour.

May I add a few more songs, which I think are essential for this project?

* "Flying"

* "Long Long Long"
this is in fact a very deep psychedelic tune. The whole atmosphere is so dark and psychy. The drum fills are great. The end is as haunting as it gets.

* "I Want You (She's So Heavy)"
I was surprised that you took in most of the Abbey Road b-side, not because it's not progressive enough, but I really didn't expect you to like it; "I Want You" is essential, especially because of the heavy guitar riffs at the end plus the big wave that swallows the song.

* "Love You To"
no explanation needed I guess

* "Revolution #9"
it's not pop, but of course the most progressive the Beatles ever went. It's great, too. It's really haunting and provokes a whole world of images in your head. It's almost as walking over battle fields and through mental hospitals in dreamlike sequences. Totally psychedelic!

* "Happiness Is A Warm Gun"
another essential one, using one of the most heavily and interestingly destorted guitars the Beatles ever used; highly progressive song structure; besides it is one of my favourites

* "Think for yourself"
fuzz-guitar, weird riffs, chords and rhythmic structure, it's all there!

* "Piggies"
you don't like harpsichord? Too bad! The middle eight is ingenious songwriting and highly psychedelic, too. And the way the harpsichord is used is quite unique. Which other pop song has a harpsichord as aggressively thumping as that?

* "Cry Baby Cry"
very good tune. Psychedelic enough, too.

* "Baby You're A Rich Man"
not Lennon's best tune. But quite psychedelic.

* "Blue Jay Way"
most essential psych track on par with "It's All Too Much" and "Northern Song"!!! Great tune with an atmosphere unparalleled in pop history.

* "Fool On The Hill"
lyricwise essential. Great psych pop tune. One of McCartney's best compositions.

* "You Know My Name (Look Up the Number)"
does it ever end? One song after the other... This one is not psychedelic, but if you consider the b-side of Abbey Road progressive this is even more so, as it puts it all into one song. 6 songs in 3 minutes. And you have Brian Jones playing the saxophone, which is psychedelic in itself!

* "Hey Bulldog"
This is one fine psychedelic rocker, that I wouldn't wanna do without.

Ah, maybe here it ends.
I think all of those are more psychedelic than "Get Back", "Birthday" and "Hello Goodbye". Those are a little too straight in my opinion.

Hey, sorry for the length of this post. Blame it on the Beatles! :lol:
 
"Blue Jay Way" is Harrison's toilet flushing opus, :flush:
Easily his worst penned effort let alone one of the lousiest Beatle tunes.
It is boring, the chorus is beyond tedious and repeated far too many times. Let alone the hokey phasing technique.
 
"Revolution #9" is interesting for the first couple of listens, otherwise it wears and grates heavily like a novelty recording. "Flight Reaction" by Calico Wall is a far, far better psychedelic pastiche of images set to music.
Calico Wall 1, Beatles 0