What exactly is a tax scam record?

Al.Burnett1966

Mark VII Class
Joined
Apr 13, 2024
Location
France
I've came across this term many times and I think I have a rough idea of what it is but I struggle to have the exact definition. From what I recall I've seen it attributed mostly to LPs issued in small quantities in the 1970s, but also about less-than-100 releases in the UK.
In that I don't really see in what way it's different from the good old small runs of self-produced 45s (and sometimes LPs) of the Garage era. Could someone explain?
 
Tax scam records are pressed but never distributed or sold, in most cases...sometimes a small amount of them are leaked out to a discount wholesaler type company. The tax scam produced records are almost always LPs. Morris Levy of Roulette records was involved with these, as was Texan Huey Meaux.
When time came to "cook" the accounting books, they would say x amount of copies were pressed, but zero or a very low quantity of the pressing was sold at retail. Thus they were able to deduct unsold copies (really just sitting in a warehouse somewhere) as a cost of doing business allowance.
The Things to Come LP is aperfect example...the group had long since dissolved by the time the LP was pressed. Tax scam issues were done with zero involvement from the performers.
 
Tax scam records are pressed but never distributed or sold, in most cases...sometimes a small amount of them are leaked out to a discount wholesaler type company. The tax scam produced records are almost always LPs. Morris Levy of Roulette records was involved with these, as was Texan Huey Meaux.
When time came to "cook" the accounting books, they would say x amount of copies were pressed, but zero or a very low quantity of the pressing was sold at retail. Thus they were able to deduct unsold copies (really just sitting in a warehouse somewhere) as a cost of doing business allowance.
The Things to Come LP is aperfect example...the group had long since dissolved by the time the LP was pressed. Tax scam issues were done with zero involvement from the performers.
Very interesting read. How did they get rid of the warehouse copies? If at all?
 
Very interesting read. How did they get rid of the warehouse copies? If at all?
Sometimes they end up in public auctions when the merchandise storage space leases expire or go unpaid.
I've heard that this was the case with Huey Meaux's tax-scam LP stock after his "morals" bust and subsequent
incarceration. Quite a boon for Gulf Coast music fans, because some of those albums are quite good: Joey Long,
Denny Ezba, Doug Sahm, Mandrake etc. etc. That Crazy Cajun label was quite a trove of "hidden" treasures.
 
There has been a lot of digging done about them. This is an excellent summary although the list of labels is not complete. There was also a story about them in Ugly Things along with a story about the bizarre tax scam label 'star' Steve Drake.


In the mid-late 1980s I saw dozens of them in a second hand store, located somewhere in Vermont or New Hampshire. I only bought a few, lacking the knowledge and turned off by the mid 1970s graphics, I believe most if not all were Guinness label which makes sense from Aaron's comments. The only one I have is by the Ultimates, a Columbus OH soul group who had a 45 on a NYC label. They, and recordings by their predecessor group the Enchanted Five made up the LP. The label is TSG and was 'rereleased' by Graham, both tax scam labels related to Lloyd Price.
 
Tax scam records are pressed but never distributed or sold, in most cases...sometimes a small amount of them are leaked out to a discount wholesaler type company. The tax scam produced records are almost always LPs. Morris Levy of Roulette records was involved with these, as was Texan Huey Meaux.
When time came to "cook" the accounting books, they would say x amount of copies were pressed, but zero or a very low quantity of the pressing was sold at retail. Thus they were able to deduct unsold copies (really just sitting in a warehouse somewhere) as a cost of doing business allowance.
The Things to Come LP is aperfect example...the group had long since dissolved by the time the LP was pressed. Tax scam issues were done with zero involvement from the performers.
You left out a crucial piece of the scam.
They would create phony invoices showing "payments" for several copies, though only a handful (25-300 copies) were actually pressed. Then they would claim the sales were minimal and they had to dump the remainder as cutouts at a loss, again creating phony invoices.
There's no such thing as "cost of doing business allowance". There's income & there's expenses. Expenses that relate to sales have to match recorded sales. Unsold records would be considered inventory, the cost of which is an asset that can only be expensed when sold. Hence the need to create phony "dump" sales.
The purpose of this was to create phony losses. The scam labels were always set up as subsidiaries of the scammers' mother labels so they could use the phony losses as offsets against the real income of the mother label. The purpose was tax avoidance, hence the term tax scam label.

Tommy James, in his autobiography, gives a good description of this in relation to Levy's Tiger Lily label. Moishe had the added advantage of owning the Strawberries record store chain to use as a conduit for the alleged cutouts.
The most famous Tiger Lily is the Stonewall LP, copies of which have gone for 5 figures.

I don't think the Things To Come LP is a tax scam album per se. The story that went around was that someone had the tapes & pressed the copies to cash in on band member Russ Kunkel having become well known in the 70s.
It came out on Century, one of the top vanity labels ("give us your tapes & we'll make you x copies of it"), no different from scores of other now known "private" garage/psych/soul/etc records. It was more like Pretty "Mustache In Your Face" where some copies were pressed without the ban knowing it existed (though IIRC, that was done by producer Michael Quinton for promotion.
Things was a scam, but not a tax scam.
 
totally unrelated to the USA tax scam scheme. pressings of 100+ were taxed in the UK, so to avoid having to pay those taxes many artists would have 99 copies made of their releases. not a 'scam' at all (at least not by the artists...)
The real 'scam' is the taxation rate in the U.K. George Harrison was absolutely right about that...even way back in 1966.
 
It was insane! 😅

1966 was the year UK celebrities ran for their lives as the whopping 95% supertax rate was imposed by Harold Wilsons Labour Government.
As Ray Davies sang on The Kinks' "End Of The Season" (from the 1967 LP Something Else):
"I just can't mix in all the clubs I know.
Now Labour's in, I have no place to go."
 
I don't think the Things To Come LP is a tax scam album per se. The story that went around was that someone had the tapes & pressed the copies to cash in on band member Russ Kunkel having become well known in the 70s.
It came out on Century, one of the top vanity labels ("give us your tapes & we'll make you x copies of it"), no different from scores of other now known "private" garage/psych/soul/etc records. It was more like Pretty "Mustache In Your Face" where some copies were pressed without the ban knowing it existed (though IIRC, that was done by producer Michael Quinton for promotion.
Things was a scam, but not a tax scam.
I I would disagree with your description of the PRETTY "Mustache..." 45 as a tax scam record. Altho it was pressed without the band's knowledge, Weakley (a/k/a Quinton) gave each band member a copy of the disc before he headed out to California with the remainder of
the pressings. And it was pressed to promote the band, NOT as a tax write-off. So, like the Things To Come LP, should not be considered a tax scam release.
 
I I would disagree with your description of the PRETTY "Mustache..." 45 as a tax scam record. Altho it was pressed without the band's knowledge, Weakley (a/k/a Quinton) gave each band member a copy of the disc before he headed out to California with the remainder of
the pressings. And it was pressed to promote the band, NOT as a tax write-off. So, like the Things To Come LP, should not be considered a tax scam release.
that's exactly what he said
 
that's exactly what he said
Thanks for that.
It was my intent to use Pretty as a comparative with the Things, to reinforce the latter wouldn't be labelled 'tax scam'.

It's interesting what CC mentions about Quinton giving copies to the band members. IIRC, the notes in the Numbero reissue imply otherwise, that they never knew it was made until being contacted for the reissue. Maybe these are recollections of different members.
 
Now does anyone have an original 1970 pressing of the Pretty 7" they would part with ?
I had two copies at different points in time, both now safely ensconced in other collections. I wonder if there are any other known copies.
The funny part is last night, I got an email from a noted collector asking if I still had a copy available. In saying 'no', I mentioned that Discogs shows 8 members with copies. I said I think 6 of hose are wrong. (Most likely individual copies of the Numero as pretty much nothing else in their collections was commensurate with it.)
 
had two copies at different points in time, both now safely ensconced in other collections. I wonder if there are any other known copies.
The funny part is last night, I got an email from a noted collector asking if I still had a copy available. In saying 'no', I mentioned that Discogs shows 8 members with copies. I said I think 6 of hose are wrong. (Most likely individual copies of the Numero as pretty much nothing else in their collections was commensurate with it.)

I know of 4 original copies in private collections here in the Kansas City area, the band's hometown. One is in a university library archive, never to see the light of day. One is cracked, one is NM and I don't know the status of the 4th, the collector who owns it is secretive about his
collection. (This copy in the secretive dude's collection + the NM copy are 2 of the 8 listed on discogs 'have' list.) All 4 were found in 'the wild,' I.e. garage/estate sale, thrift shop, etc. The NM copy came from an estate sale about 15 years back and when I told Bob Theen (Fab 4/Pretty guitarist) about it turning up, he said it probably was the copy that belonged to one of his former band mates, who had passed away a short time before the estate sale. Theen was the one who informed me that all of the band received a copy of the disc before Weakley went to CA. He was the last of the ex-members to hold onto his copy until approx 10 years ago when he sold it to one of the Numero partners.
The first copy that I was ever aware of was when a Michigan LP psych collector told me about his copy, this was way back in the early '80s, if memory serves. Don't know how/where he got his copy and don't know where it is now, he passed away in 2021. Perhaps one of the 2 copies that you owned was this one ?
So that's either 7 or 8 copies known for certain to exist.